Why Does Retained Recruitment Win Every Time?
Debbie Morrison • July 24, 2024

Ever wonder why your recruitment process seems never-ending?

Are you constantly juggling resumes and interviews and still not finding the right fit?


Let’s break down the difference between contingency and retained recruitment and why retained recruitment is ultimately the wiser choice.

Quick vs. Quality: What’s Your Priority?


Contingency recruitment might seem appealing with its quick results and competitive edge, but are you sacrificing quality for speed?


You end up with a pool of candidates, but how many of them are truly the right fit?


Agencies working on a contingency basis often juggle multiple roles simultaneously, giving each one minimal attention just to get the job done.


This often results in a shallow candidate search and less dedication to finding the perfect match.


You’re relying on chance rather than a thorough, strategic search.


Contingency = by chance


Contingent recruitment typically yields a low 25% fill rate.


Recruiters pour 100% effort into securing fees but often work without guaranteed payment.


Focusing on quick placements can compromise candidate quality and lead to less productive outcomes.


Retained Recruitment: A Robust Approach


Retained recruitment is different.


It’s about taking the time to find quality candidates who fit your specific needs.


This method involves a robust methodology covering the entire market, ensuring that every potential candidate is considered.


Retained recruitment targets a broader and often more qualified pool by focusing on passive candidates interested in opportunities but not actively looking for them.


Did you know that 75% of candidates are not actively seeking roles?


Our approach is designed to engage this group by thinking ahead and understanding their motivations.


Our proactive, continuous mapping of the executive and senior talent pool, cultivation of relationships, and global networks offer unmatched access to leadership talent.


The Cost of a Bad Hire


Let’s face it: a bad hire can be a costly mistake.


Imagine hiring someone who looked great on paper but turned out to be a poor fit for your company.


The financial implications are significant, but the impact on team morale and productivity can be even more damaging.


A bad hire can set your company back in more ways than one.


Addressing Your Challenges


As a senior decision maker in leadership or HR, your main goals are to meet budget expectations, hire the right people, and ensure company growth.


But the challenges are real: tight budgets, short timelines, and finding candidates who fit your company’s culture and strategy.


ELR Executive's retained recruitment tackles these challenges directly.


Our approach ensures a quick, efficient hiring process.


We provide full transparency and regular updates, so you’ll never have to wonder about the status of your search.


Why Choose Retained Recruitment with ELR Executive?


The current market requires recruiters to conduct a thorough candidate search.


The best talent is harder to acquire than ever before, and they need more than a LinkedIn message to pique their interest in a new opportunity.


If the client is looking for the best candidate in the market at the time, they need to invest in a retained search.


At ELR Executive, we understand the importance of that.


Our retained recruitment service is designed to save you time and effort by conducting a comprehensive search tailored to your needs.


We leverage market mapping to identify the best talent, including those passive candidates who are not actively looking but are open to the right opportunity.


Our approach ensures that no stone is left unturned in the search for your perfect fit.


We discreetly deliver C-Suite, D-Suite, Executive, and Senior operational appointments across all departments and divisions essential to any business, ensuring our clients get the management expertise they need to achieve the growth they want.


Isn’t it time you had a recruitment process that worked for you, not against you?


Let’s discuss how ELR Executives’s retained recruitment can help you achieve your goals and streamline your hiring process.

A woman is holding two bottles of cosmetics in her hands.
By John Elliott April 21, 2025
Australia’s health, wellness, and supplements sector isn’t just growing. It’s exploding. From functional drinks to adaptogenic gummies, wellness brands have gone from niche to mainstream in record time. The industry is now worth over $5.6 billion, up from $4.7 billion in 2020 — a 19% growth in just three years. IBISWorld projects continued expansion with a CAGR of 5.3% through 2028. But behind the glossy packaging and influencer campaigns, something else is happening: the regulators have arrived. And most wellness brands? They’re underprepared. From Trend to Target The boom brought founders, fitness coaches, nutritionists, and marketing entrepreneurs into the supplement space. What many built was impressive. But what most forgot was how fast wellness moves from enthusiasm to enforcement. With more than 40 infringement notices and administrative sanctions in Q1 alone, the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) strengthened enforcement of the Therapeutic Goods Advertising Code in early 2024. Prominent companies were named in public. Soon after, the ACCC revised its guidelines for influencer marketing disclosures and launched a campaign against the use of pseudoscientific terminology in product marketing. TGA head Professor Anthony Lawler noted in March 2024: “We’re seeing an unacceptably high level of non-compliance, particularly around unsubstantiated therapeutic claims.” In short: credibility is the new battleground. Why Sales-First Leadership is Failing Too many brands are still led by executives whose playbooks were built on community engagement, retail hustle, and Instagram fluency. That got them early traction. But it won’t keep them compliant — or protect them from an investor exodus when the lawsuits begin. The biggest risks now are not formulation errors. They’re: Claims breaches Compliance negligence Advertising missteps Unqualified health endorsements Reputational collapse through regulatory exposure And these aren’t theoretical. The TGA pulled 197 listed medicines from the market in 2023 alone — a 42% increase on the previous year — due to non-compliant claims or sponsor breaches. What the Next Wellness Leader Looks Like This is where many boards and founders face a difficult transition. The next generation of leadership in wellness isn’t defined by hustle. It’s defined by: Deep regulatory fluency Cross-functional commercial leadership (eComm, retail, pharma, FMCG) Reputation management under pressure Ability to scale with scrutiny, not just speed The leadership profiles now needed aren’t coming out of marketing agencies — they’re coming out of pharmaceuticals, healthtech, and functional food. They’ve sat on regulatory committees. They’ve built compliance-first commercial strategies. They understand how to win trust, not just impressions. Yes, this might feel like a shift away from the founder-led energy that made these brands exciting. But it’s not about slowing down. It’s about making sure you’re still standing when the music stops. Where the Gaps Are The underlying problem isn’t just non-compliance. It's immaturity in structural leadership. The majority of wellness brands haven't developed: An accountable governance structure; a scalable compliance architecture; a risk-aware marketing culture; and any significant succession planning beyond the founder. In fact, a 2023 survey by Complementary Medicines Australia found that only 22% of wellness businesses had dedicated compliance leadership at executive level, and just 14% had formal succession plans in place. This isn’t sustainable — not at scale, and certainly not under scrutiny. Final Thought The wellness boom isn’t over. But the rules have changed. Rapid growth is no longer enough. The brands that win from here will be those with: A compliance culture baked in Leadership teams built for complexity A board that sees regulation not as a barrier, but a brand advantage Those who don’t? They could be one audit away from crisis.
A Farmer walking through a barn, using a laptop with cows eating hay nearby.
By John Elliott April 17, 2025
Australia’s meat sector is facing a leadership vacuum. Explore the hidden crisis behind staffing, succession, and ESG risk in food manufacturing.